| Big North Conference |
| |
| United |
| Softball |
| 2011-2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Victoria D’Addario | DePaul | Junior | First Base |
| Carly Piccinich | IHA | Senior | Infield |
| Christina Gonzalez | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Infield |
| Emily Cutler | DePaul | Senior | Infield |
| Rachel Pollard | IHA | Sophomore | Outfield |
| Angelina McGuire | IHA | Sophomore | Outfield |
| Brittany Mangan | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Outfield |
| Christina Martinez | DePaul | Junior | Catcher |
| Ally Vergona | IHA | Junior | Catcher |
| Steph Thomas | IHA | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| Ashley LaGuardia | DePaul | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| Erica Correa | IHA | Senior | At Large |
| Daniella Ibarra | IHA | Sophomore | At Large |
| Cassisy Trause | IHA | Junior | At Large |
| | | | |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Abby Holmes | IHA | Senior | First |
| Marissa Heyer | AHA | Junior | Infield |
| Alyssa Neal | Paramus Catholic | Sophomore | Infield |
| Janelle Marchesani | Paramus Catholic | Junior | Infield |
| Ronnie Vergara | DePaul | Freshman | Infield |
| Abby Symons | DePaul | Sophomore | Outfield |
| Nicole Macaluso | AHA | Sophomore | Outfield |
| Brianna Francis | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Outfield |
| Samantha Held | Paramus Catholic | Sophomore | Catcher |
| Samantha Buse | Paramus Catholic | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| Lauren Saxenian | AHA | Junior | Pitcher |
| Shannon Walsh | DePaul | Senior | At Large |
| Kallie Francis | Paramus Catholic | Senior | At Large |
| Deanna Burbridge | AHA | Freshman | At Large |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | | |
| Erin Dubee (12)/Amanda Pepe (12) | AHA | | |
| Mary Farrington (12)/Natasha Duplain (10) | DePaul | | |
| Tiffany Maresca (10)/Olivia D’Amato(10) | Paramus Catholic | | |
| Nicole Napolitano (12)/ Sephanie Schulz (12) | IHA | | |
| |
| Coach of the year | Sue Parker/Anthonly Larezza |
| School | Depaul/IHA |
