| Big North Conference |
| |
| American |
| Softball |
| 2011-2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Victoria Smith | Dumont | Senior | First Base |
| Julie Rovito | Ridgefield Park | Sophomore | First Base |
| Shannon Oliver | Dumont | Senior | Infield |
| Jess Domke | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Infield |
| Caitlin McKenna | Fort Lee | Sophomore | Infield |
| Sophia Ivezaj | Cliffside Park | Senior | Infield |
| Kristie Visaggio | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Outfield |
| Elena Rapp | Cliffside Park | Senior | Outfield |
| Nicole Farber | Fort Lee | Senior | Outfield |
| Meghan Schneider | Westwood | Senior | Outfield |
| Megan Gimson | Fort Lee | Senior | Catcher |
| Juliann Barclay | Dumont | Senior | Catcher |
| Dana Klarer | Westwood | Junior | Pitcher |
| Amanda Maldonando | Fort Lee | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| Allie Lawlor | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Pitcher |
| Katherine Hartley | Westwood | Senior | At Large |
| Valerie Garris | Ridgefield Park | Senior | At Large |
| Katelyn Arbadji | Dumont | Junior | At Large |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Kayla Marquez | Cliffside Park | Sophomore | First Base |
| Anthe Nikolaidis | Fort Lee | Senior | First Base |
| Julia Senkevich | Westwood | Junior | Infield |
| Jillian Scrivanich | Fort Lee | Senior | Infield |
| Emily Molk | Westwood | Freshman | Infield |
| Star Kontogiannis | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Outfield |
| Kristie Valerio | Cliffside Park | Senior | Outfield |
| Kelly Ortiz | Dumont | Senior | Outfield |
| Mary Schneider | Westwood | Senior | Outfield |
| Jennifer Keri | Westwood | Sophomore | Catcher |
| Natalie Gomez | Ridgfield Park | Junior | Catrcher |
| Kim Winant | Dumont | Senior | Pitcher |
| Amanda Frato | Cliffside Park | Junior | Pitcher |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | |
| Irene Kontogiannis,(10)/Tessa Carapolo,(11) | Ridgefield Park | | |
| Raabe Alves, (11)/Daniela Carratozzolo,(12) | Cliffside Park | | |
| Cassidy Rooney/Gina Battaglia | Westwood | Junior | |
| Amanda Vietri/Lindsey Sansone | Dumont | Senior | |
| Haruhi Noaki/Nasuka Mizuma | Fort Lee | Freshman | |
| |
| Coach of the year | Dan Rattacasa |
| School | Westwood |
