All-Division: American
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| American | ||||||||
| Softball | ||||||||
| 2016 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Jennifer Sweeney | Dumont | Junior | Pitcher | |||||
| Danielle Sinclair | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Pitcher | |||||
| Devin Davis | Dumont | Junior | Catcher | |||||
| Allie Paseschnick | Ridgefield Park | Junior | First Base | |||||
| Melissa Atkinson | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Sarah Diaz | Fort Lee | Junior | Infield | |||||
| Courtney Deloughery | Dumont | Junior | Infield | |||||
| Rachel Domke | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Outfield | |||||
| Jessica Lombardi | Cliffside Park | Senior | Outfield | |||||
| Lauren Naveo | Dumont | Sophomore | Outfield | |||||
| Kerry Tellian | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Open | |||||
| Ariana Pena | Dumont | Sophomore | Open | |||||
| Allie Botto | Cliffside Park | Freshman | Open | |||||
| Daniela Gurski | Dwight Morrow | Sophomore | Open | |||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Destiny Tansey | Cliffside Park | Sophomore | Pitcher | |||||
| Nicole Maldonado | Fort Lee | Junior | Catcher | |||||
| Shavini Patel | Dumont | Senior | First Base | |||||
| Gabby Cortes | Ridgefield Park | Freshman | Infield | |||||
| Gianni Perez | Cliffside Park | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Alex Lindstrom | Dumont | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Ellie Schulman | Fort Lee | Senior | Outfield | |||||
| Janaya Gaetan | Ridgefield Park | Sophomore | Outfield | |||||
| Jasmine Vera | Dumont | Junior | Outfield | |||||
| Soubia Hassan | Dwight Morrow | Freshman | Open | |||||
| Amanda Armstrong | Cliffside Park | Freshman | Open | |||||
| Jackie McKenna | Fort Lee | Junior | Open | |||||
| Lara Amato | Cliffside Park | Junior | Open | |||||
| Mackenzie Tamburro | Dumont | Freshman | Open | |||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Nathalie Arboleda | Ridgefield Park | Senior | ||||||
| Alyssa Flowers | Ridgefield Park | Junior | ||||||
| Tommasina DiMeglio | Fort Lee | Sophomore | ||||||
| Athena Sinisi | Fort Lee | Freshman | ||||||
| Ruby Maury-Jorge | Dwight Morrow | Junior | ||||||
| Ashley Surowiec | Dwight Morrow | Sophomore | ||||||
| Ariana Martoral | Dumont | Freshman | ||||||
| Rachel Jones | Cliffside Park | Junior | ||||||
| Monique Berisha | Cliffside Park | Junior | ||||||
| Coach of the year | Kendal George | |||||||
| School | Dumont | |||||||