United: All-Division
| Big North Conference | |||||
| United | |||||
| Girls Volleyball | |||||
| 2012 | |||||
| 1st Team All-Division | |||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | School | Year | |||
| Georgette Smith | Paramus Catholic | Senior | |||
| Lisa Sesink-Clee | Holy Angels | Senior | |||
| Emily Kolodka | Holy Angels | Junior | |||
| Cara Silvestri | DePaul | Senior | |||
| Cassie Hackett | DePaul | Senior | |||
| Erin Gloor | DePaul | Junior | |||
| Nia Reed | IHA | Junior | |||
| Michelle Cruz | IHA | Senior | |||
| Caitlyn Floyd | IHA | Freshman | |||
| Larysa Iwaskiw | IHA | Junior | |||
| 2nd Team All-Division | |||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | School | Year | |||
| Jennifer Pagano | IHA | Senior | |||
| Ashley Agnello | IHA | Senior | |||
| Jessica Breen | Paramus Catholic | Junior | |||
| Catherine Mulick | Paramus Catholic | Junior | |||
| Anna Kohli | Holy Angels | Senior | |||
| Cate Slepian | Holy Angels | Senior | |||
| Abby Simons | DePaul | Junior | |||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | |||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | School | Year | |||
| Leslie Mariano | DePaul | Senior | |||
| Lauren Dickerson | Holy Angels | Freshman | |||
| Dana Scheffler | IHA | Junior | |||
| Alyssa Neal | Paramus Catholic | Junior | |||
| Coach of the year | n/a | ||||
| School | n/a | ||||