American: All-Division
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| American | ||||||||
| Girls Soccer | ||||||||
| 2012 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position | |||||
| Samaria McCullough | Cliffside | Senior | F | |||||
| Amanda Fisco | Dumont | Junior | F | |||||
| Caitlin McKenna | Fort Lee | Junior | F | |||||
| Kassi Reagan | Dumont | Junior | F | |||||
| Patricia Downing | Dumont | Senior | MID | |||||
| Ashley Castillo | Ridgefield Park | Sophomore | MID | |||||
| Abigal Light | Dwight Morrow | Sophomore | MID | |||||
| Luisa Arias | Dwight Morrow | Senior | D | |||||
| Liz Branagh | Dumont | Senior | D | |||||
| Jessica Domke | Ridgefield Park | Senior | D | |||||
| Nicola Goddard | Dwight Morrow | Senior | D | |||||
| Margo Grisanti | Fort Lee | Senior | D | |||||
| Syria McCullough | Cliffside Park | Junior | D | |||||
| Sunya Mouada | Ridgefield Park | Junior | D | |||||
| Kellie Lane | Ridgefield Park | Senior | GK | |||||
| Gina Yannette | Dumont | Senior | GK | |||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position | |||||
| Lucy Dellaquila | Fort Lee | Senior | F | |||||
| Rosa Martinez | Ridgefield Park | Senior | F | |||||
| Odelia Cordova | Cliffside Park | Sophomore | F | |||||
| Alicia Pena | Dwight Morrow | Sophomore | F | |||||
| Katelyn Arbadji | Dumont | Senior | MID | |||||
| Larissa Andehertz | Fort Lee | Senior | MID | |||||
| Karina Borda | Ridgefield Park | Junior | MID | |||||
| Daniela Molinaro | Fort Lee | Junior | MID | |||||
| Natalie Nunez | Cliffside Park | Junior | MID | |||||
| Julie Rovito | Ridgefield Park | Junior | MID | |||||
| Samantha Richter | Dumont | Freshman | MID | |||||
| Aashna Jain | Fort Lee | Senior | D | |||||
| Amina Wangongo | Dwight Morrow | Senior | D | |||||
| Zoe Leonard | Dumont | Junior | D | |||||
| Jessica Molinaro | Fort Lee | D | ||||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position | |||||
| Genesis Garcia | Cliffside Park | D | ||||||
| Emily Stein | Dwight Morrow | MID | ||||||
| Momoko Oi | Dumont | Senior | D | |||||
| Ashley Jenq | Fort Lee | Junior | F | |||||
| Melissa Atkinson | Ridgefield Park | D | ||||||
| Coach of the year | Jill Guider | |||||||
| School | Cliffside Park | |||||||