| Big North Conference |
| |
| American |
| Girls Swimming & Diving |
| 2016-2017 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Alexa O’Connor, Irene Keh, Kaitlyn Yoo, Meredith Gioia | NVD | 0 | 200 MR |
| Juli Hyatt | Tenafly | Senior | 200 FREE |
| Rachel Woods-Bannan | NVD | Sophomore | 200 IM |
| Abby Choi | Ramapo | Junior | 50 FREE |
| Cleopatra Lim | Tenafly | Junior | 100 FLY |
| Kaitlyn Yoo | NVD | Sophomore | 100 FREE |
| Gabrielle Cervone | NVD | Junior | 500 FREE |
| Kaitlyn Yoo, Carly Rotile, Alexa O’Connor, Gabrielle Cervone | NVD | – | 200 FR |
| Molly Arts | Ramapo | Freshman | 100 BACK |
| Heather Wong | Ramsey | Senior | 100 BREAST |
| Rachel Woods-Bannan, Clara Lee, Meredith Gioia, Gabrielle Cervone | NVD | – | 400 FR |
| Olivia Schiackman | Mahwah | Junior | OPEN |
| Andrea Anacker | Tenafly | Senior | OPEN |
| Alexa O’Connor | NVD | Sophomore | OPEN |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Andrea Anacker, Juli Hyatt, Cleopatra Lim, Samantha Simotas | Tenafly | – | 200 MR |
| Anna Wadsworth | Tenafly | Junior | 200 FREE |
| Clara Lee | NVD | Junior | 200 IM |
| Kristen Lee | Mahwah | Senior | 50 FREE |
| Madison Hoitsma | Ramsey | Senior | 100 FLY |
| Meredith Gioia | NVD | Sophomore | 100 FREE |
| Sofia Zimmerman | Ramapo | Junior | 500 FREE |
| Molly Arts, Emma Perry, Sofia Zimmerman, Abby Choi | Ramapo | – | 200 FR |
| Courtney Kim | NVD | Junior | 100 BACK |
| Irene Keh | NVD | Freshman | 100 BREAST |
| Andrea Anacker, Anna Wadsworth, Juli Hyatt, Cleopatra Lim | Tenafly | – | 400 FR |
| Gabby Macke | Ramapo | Freshman | OPEN |
| Julia Seelin | Ramsey | Sophomore | OPEN |
| Samantha Simotas | Tenafly | Senior | OPEN |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Miruna Baciu | Tenafly | Junior | 0 |
| Emma Perry | Ramapo | Senior | 0 |
| Sofia Kontolios | NV-D | Sophomore | 0 |
| Sarah Haber | Mahwah | Junior | 0 |
| Aislinn Farley | Ramsey | Sophomore | 0 |
| |
| Coach of the year | Samantha Singer |
| School | NV Demarest |
