| Big North Conference |
| |
| United |
| Football |
| 2014 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Rashan Gary | Paramus Catholic | Junior | Defensive Line |
| Sal Mauro | Bergen Catholic | Junior | Defensive Line |
| Kyle Kleinberg | Don Bosco Prep. | Senior | Defensive Line |
| Kwanii Figueroa | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Defensive Line |
| Ibn Foster | St. Joseph Regional High School | Junior | Defensive Line |
| Quayshon Alexander | DePaul Catholic | Junior | Defensive Line |
| Anthony Malaguti | Don Bosco Prep. | Senior | Linebacker |
| Saleem Brightwell | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Linebacker |
| Joseph Giles-Harris | St. Joseph Regional High School | Senior | Linebacker |
| Kyle Cook | Bergen Catholic | Senior | Linebacker |
| Lawrence Stevens | Don Bosco Prep. | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Nagee Clayton | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Devin Cividini | St. Joseph Regional High School | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Emmanuel Appiah | Bergen Catholic | Junior | Defensive Back |
| Curtis Oliver | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Defensive Back |
| John Bowers | Bergen Catholic | Senior | Punter |
| Leo Vagias | Don Bosco Prep | Senior | Punt Kicker |
| Gavin Haggerty | St. Joseph Regional | Senior | Punt Kicker |
| | | | |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Frank Feaster | Bergen Catholic | Junior | Defensive Line |
| Andre Evans | DePaul Catholic | Junior | Defensive Line |
| Brandon Simon | Don Bosco Prep. | Junior | Defensive Line |
| Joseph Baccas | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Defensive Line |
| Amir Arrington | DePaul Catholic | Senior | Linebacker |
| Zach Chakonis | Don Bosco Prep. | Senior | Linebacker |
| Jamad Thomas | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Linebacker |
| Louis Acceus | St. Joseph Regional High School | Sophomore | Linebacker |
| Jack Reilly | Bergen Catholic | Senior | Bergen Catholic |
| John Thomas Giles-Harris | St. Joseph Regional High School | Junior | Defensive Back |
| Matthew Sherlock | Bergen Catholic | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Kwadir Brown | DePaul Catholic | Junior | Defensive Back |
| Troy Gethers | St. Joseph Regional High School | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Joseph Neglia | St. Joseph Regional High School | Junior | Punter |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Sabastian Calixte | Bergen Catholic | | Defense |
| Jermey Brown | DePaul Catholic | | Defense |
| William Mack | Don Bosco Prep. | | Defense |
| Louie Gartner | Paramus Catholic | | Defense |
| Austin Triglia | St. Joseph Regional High School | | Defense |
| | | | |
| | | | | | | | | |
| Coach of the year | Nunzio Campanielle | | | | | |
| School | Bergen Catholic |
