| Big North Conference |
| |
| National |
| Football |
| 2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Ben Davis | Old Tappan | Senior | Tight End |
| Quinn Mcginely | Northern Valley Demarest | Junior | Tight End |
| Justin Waller | Tenafly | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Kyle Allegrini | Lakeland | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Joey Jordan | Lakeland | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Skylar Dennerlien | Northern Valley Demarest | Senior | Tackle |
| Doug Bobo | Lakeland | Senior | Tackle |
| Jeremy Manning | Lakeland | Senior | Guard |
| Tommy Kramer | Old Tappan | Senior | Guard |
| Joe Portella | Lakeland | Junior | Center |
| John Trainor | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Running Back |
| Matt Horowitz | Northern Valley Demarest | Senior | Running Back |
| Dave Shellhammer | Lakeland | Senior | Running Back |
| Steve Sobo | Tenafly | Senior | Quarterback |
| Cory Caddell | Lakeland | Senior | Quarterback |
| Ray Nyhuis | Lakeland | Junior | Place Kicker |
| | | | |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Nicholas Blake | Tenafly | Junior | Tight End |
| Danny Torres | Tenafly | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Jared Levitt | Tenafly | Junior | Wide Receiver |
| Anthony Saro | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Junior | Tackle |
| Matt Goodman | Northern Valley Demarest | Senior | Guard |
| Andrew Carpanini | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Guard |
| Anthony Koles | Tenafly | Senior | Center |
| Zach Frohlich | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Running Back |
| Austin Fouch | Northern Valley Demarest | Senior | Running Back |
| Danny Thompson | Indian Hills | Senior | Quarterback |
| Dominck Fazio | Northern Valley Demarest | Junior | Place Kicker |
| Zach Mazar | Lakeland | Junior | Tackle |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year |
| Anthony Belfert | Northern Valley Demarest | Junior |
| John-Jay Pontrelli | Northern Valley Demarest | Senior |
| Brendan Carti | Indian Hills | Sophomore |
| Chad Campbell | Indian Hills | Senior |
| Adam Wallerstein | Lakeland | Junior |
| Steve Thompson | Lakeland | Junior |
| Christian Runza | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Junior |
| Garrett Sytsma | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior |
| Tommy Lee | Tenafly | Senior |
| Robert Peters | Tenafly | Senior |
| |
| Coach of the year | Bill Weigel |
| School | Lakeland |
