| Big North Conference |
| |
| United |
| Baseball |
| 2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Rob Kaminsky | St. Joseph’s | Junior | Pitcher |
| Tom Burns | Don Bosco | Senior | Pitcher |
| Nick Cuono | St. Joseph’s | Senior | DePaul |
| Andrew Herrera | Don Bosco | Junior | Catcher |
| Corey Lerche | St. Joseph’s | Senior | First Base |
| Matt Dacey | Don Bosco | Senior | First Base |
| Garrett Luna | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Infielder |
| George Iskendarian | Don Bosco | Senior | Infielder |
| Robert Quigley | Bergen Catholic | Senior | Infielder |
| Nick Wolyniec | St. Joseph’s | Senior | Infielder |
| Sean Jones | De Paul | Senior | Outfield |
| Mark Cieslak | St. Joseph’s | Senior | Outfield |
| Mike Meccia | Don Bosco | Senior | Outfield |
| Ryan Kelly | Bergen Catholic | Senior | Outfield |
| Joe Purritano | Don Bosco | Senior | DH |
| Nick Fondacaro | DePaul | Senior | Utility |
| | | | |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Mike Gomez | Don Bosco | Senior | Pitcher |
| Jeff Granger | Bergen Catholic | Junior | Pitcher |
| Mike Lembo | De Paul | Senior | Pitcher |
| Zach Cerbo | Bergen Catholic | Junior | Catcher |
| John Scarr | De Paul | Junior | Catcher |
| Grant Van Orden | Don Bosco | Senior | Infield |
| AJ Gallagher | Bergen Catholic | Junior | Infield |
| Chris Chiaradio | St. Joseph’s | Senior | Infield |
| James Colacci | Paramus Catholic | Junior | Infield |
| David Sdrougais | Paramus | Sophomore | Outfield |
| Mike Sutherland | Bergen Catholic | Senior | Outfield |
| Mike Sweeney | De Paul | Senior | Outfield |
| Ken Megan | Paramus Catholic | Sophomore | DH |
| Alex Woinski | St. Joseph’s | Junior | DH |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | |
| John Ferrer & Carlo Ruffino | Paramus Catholic |
| Matt Millus & Greg Bargiel | Bergen Catholic |
| Garrett Vinnet & Steve Lombardi | Don Bosco |
| George Monsen & Matt Betz | De Paul |
| Dylan Scance & Matt Kozuch | St. Joseph’s |
| |
| Coach of the year | Mike Rooney | |
| School | Don Bosco |
