| Big North Conference |
| |
| Patriot |
| Baseball |
| 2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Chris Baldi | Mahwah | Junior | Pitcher |
| Mike Niego | Pascack Valley | Senior | Pitcher |
| Dan Green | Indian Hills | Senior | Pitcher |
| Devin Torres | Indian Hills | Sophomore | Catcher |
| Dan Quintanna | Bergenfield | Senior | Catcher |
| PJ Scandariato | Ramsey | Senior | First Base |
| Ryan McNaughton | Pascack Valley | Sophomore | Infield |
| Cole Fabio | Mahwah | Junior | Infield |
| Adam Hanig | Mahwah | Senior | Infield |
| Tom Cancalori | Indian Hills | Senior | Infield |
| Brandon Martinez | River Dell | Junior | Outfield |
| Brendan Brown | Mahwah | Senior | Outfield |
| Nick Di Spoto | Ramsey | Junior | Outfield |
| Marco Baratte | Tenaflty | | DH |
| Ryan Duran | River Dell | | Utility |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Mike Cordes | Bergenfield | Senior | Pitcher |
| Mitch Reichenberg | Tenafly | Senior | Pitcher |
| Austin Solecitto | Indian Hills | Senior | Pitcher |
| Alex Dermer | River Dell | Senior | Catcher |
| Joe Salerno | Ramsey | Senior | Catcher |
| Peter Fiumefreddo | Indian Hills | Senior | First Base |
| John Budka | River Dell | Senior | Infield |
| Tim Barnes | River Dell | Junior | Infield |
| Kevin Welch | Tenafly | Senior | Infield |
| Pat Carrigan | Ramsey | Junior | Outfied |
| Zach Costa | Pascack Valley | Senior | Outfield |
| Mike Oliver | River Dell | Senior | Outfield |
| Jorge Peraltra | Indian Hills | Junior | DH |
| Shane Woulfel | Mahwah | Sophomore | Utility |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | |
| Ryan McDonough & Evan Stern | River Dell |
| Nick DeNorscia & Matt Mirkovic | Bergenfield |
| Anthony Gould & Steve Sob | Tenafly |
| Ryan Henderson & Matt Kearns | Pascack Valley |
| Matt Krupa & Andy Shuart | Mahwah |
| Gilbert Smolenski & Brady Altana | Indian Hills |
| Reid Nelson & Patrick Kiley (Ramsey) |
| |
| Coach of the year | Jeff Remo | |
| School | Mahwah |
