| Big North Conference |
| |
| National |
| Baseball |
| 2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Ari Kaufman | Ramapo | | Pitcher |
| Bernard Brito | Fair Lawn | | Pitcher |
| Josh Garran | Old Tappan | | Pitcher |
| Joe Scaglione | Ramapo | | Catcher |
| Lucas Mazurek | Old Tappan | | First Base |
| Luke Iovino | Demarest | Senior | Infield |
| Vin Capazzi | Old Tappan | | Infield |
| Chris Liquori | Ramapo | | Infield |
| Tony Gandolfo | Northern Highlands | | Infield |
| Alex Nickles | Ramapo | | Outfield |
| John Trainor | Old Tappan | | Outfield |
| Billy Taylor | Northern Highlands | | Outfield |
| Cory Sala | Ramapo | | DH |
| Matt Osieja | Ramapo | | Utility |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Troy Elias | Demarest | Junior | Pitcher |
| Chris Nardone | Northern Highlands | | Pitcher |
| Kevin Benjamin | Fair Lawn | | Catcher |
| Steve Di Bella | Northern Highlands | | Catcher |
| Brandon Ulloa | Northern Highlands | | First Base |
| Jon Avallone | Demarest | Junior | Infield |
| Dan Licamara | Fair Lawn | | Infield |
| Garrett McGovern | Northern Highlands | | Infield |
| Bobby Hoberman | Demarest | Senior | Outfield |
| Sean Haveron | Old Tappan | | Outfield |
| Sean Milnes | Fair Lawn | | Outfield |
| Andrew Mamunes | Northern Highlands | | Outfield |
| Chris Powers | Northern Highlands | | DH |
| Kris Lachapel | Fair Lawn | | DH |
| Rob Hinchon | Northern Highlands | | Utility |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | |
| Sam Pecka & Austin Grillo | Ramapo |
| Joe McVey & Matt Loughlin | Demarest |
| Jack Flynn & Matt Schwartz | Northern Highlands |
| Andrew Esposito & Sam Berowitz | Fair Lawn |
| Chris Pinelli & Matt Pacicco | Old Tappan |
| |
| Coach of the year | Mickey Hunt | |
| School | Ramapo |
