| Big North Conference |
| |
| American |
| Baseball |
| 2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Bryan Burd | Dumont | Junior | Pitcher |
| Joe Crespo | Cliffside Park | Junior | Pitcher |
| Connor O’Grady | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Pitcher |
| Mark Alberque | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Catcher |
| Kris Dodge | Fort Lee | Senior | First Base |
| Eddie Nikocevic | Cliffside Park | Freshman | Infielder |
| Ross Fasman | Fort Lee | Senior | Infielder |
| Charles Lomolino | Westwood | Senior | Infielder |
| Anthony Hoagland | Dumont | Junior | Outfielder |
| Nick Gogic | Fort Lee | Senior | Outfielder |
| Sean Sniffen | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Outfielder |
| Tom Vorvolakos | Westwood | Senior | Outfielder |
| Alex Alberque | Ridgefield Park | Senior | DH |
| Derek Hyland | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Utility |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Pat Darcy | Fort Lee | Junior | Pitcher |
| Dean Badach | Westwood | Junior | Pitcher |
| Bryan Contino | Dumont | Senior | Pitcher |
| Evan McLaughlin | Westwood | Senior | Pitcher |
| Joaquin Melo | Cliffside Park | Junior | Catcher |
| Richie Espinal | Ridgefield Park | Junior | First Base |
| Nick Markey | Westwood | Junior | Infielder |
| Nick Gentile | Fort Lee | Junior | Infielder |
| Brian Kraljic | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Infielder |
| Mike Madera | Cliffside Park | Junior | Infielder |
| Matthew Barone | Dumont | Senior | Outfielder |
| Evan Sophius | Fort Lee | Senior | Outfielder |
| Chris Fitzgerald | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Outfielder |
| Mike D’Ambrosio | Westwood | Junior | Outfielder |
| Eddie Capone, Mike Donellan | Dumont | Senior | DH/Utility |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Max Walter, Henry Meneses | Dwight Morrow | Senior | |
| Julian Johnson, Sean BroKowski | Ridgefield Park | Junior | |
| Alex Ritter, Justin Parra | Fort Lee | Sophomore | |
| Fabian Gashi, Francisco Osorio | Cliffside Park | Junior | |
| Dylan Evans, Chris Napoli | Westwood | Senior | |
| |
| Coach of the year | Pete Kraljic | |
| School | Ridgefield Park |
