All-Division: National
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| National | ||||||||
| Wrestling | ||||||||
| 2015-2016 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Matthew Murawski | Old Tappan | Sophomore | 106 | |||||
| Robbie Natelli | Pascack Valley | Sophomore | 113 | |||||
| Nolan Shields | Pascack Valley | Sophomore | 120 | |||||
| John Pabst | Old Tappan | Junior | 126 | |||||
| Matt Beyer | Pascack Valley | Freshman | 132 | |||||
| Aidan Mayer | Demarest | Senior | 138 | |||||
| Declan Ward | Old Tappan | Junior | 145 | |||||
| Gavin Connelly | Old Tappan | Junior | 152 | |||||
| Tyler Mullen | Old Tappan | Senior | 160 | |||||
| Ben Hakim | Teaneck | Senior | 170 | |||||
| Andrew Arakelian | Old Tappan | Senior | 182 | |||||
| Joseph Jordan | Old Tappan | Senior | 195 | |||||
| Jedh Downey | Old Tappan | Senior | 220 | |||||
| Robert Torres | Bergenfield | Junior | 285 | |||||
| Amichai Ohring | Demarest | Junior | 0 | |||||
| Andrew Cometa | Old Tappan | Senior | 0 | |||||
| Nick Timpanaro | Pascack Valley | Senior | 0 | |||||
| Nick Weber | Demarest | Freshman | 106 | |||||
| Andrew Dippolito | Old Tappan | Freshman | 113 | |||||
| Robert Barzelatto | Old Tappan | Junior | 120 | |||||
| Quinton Navarro | Teaneck | Junior | 126 | |||||
| Peter Andresen | Old Tappan | Junior | 132 | |||||
| Lawrence Ortiz | Teaneck | Senior | 138 | |||||
| Carlos Haynes | Bergenfield | Junior | 145 | |||||
| William Morris | Pascack Valley | Sophomore | 152 | |||||
| Nick DiStaulo | Tenafly | Freshman | 160 | |||||
| Casey Lewis | Pascack Valley | Sophomore | 170 | |||||
| Ryan Welch | Tenafly | Junior | 182 | |||||
| Bailey Paster | Demarest | Sophomore | 195 | |||||
| Joe Schnugg | Pascack Valley | Senior | 220 | |||||
| Joe Figueroa | Pascack Valley | Senior | 285 | |||||
| Dylan Barry | Demarest | Sophomore | 0 | |||||
| Stefan Casey | Old Tappan | Junior | 0 | |||||
| Thomas Rafferty | Tenafly | Junior | 0 | |||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Justin Mignott | Teaneck | Senior | 0 | |||||
| Christopher Martinez | Teaneck | Senior | 0 | |||||
| Jack DeSalvo | Tenafly | Junior | 0 | |||||
| Dan Birger | Tenafly | Senior | 0 | |||||
| Mike Martino | Pascack Valley | Senior | 0 | |||||
| Dan Schneiderman | Pascack Valley | Senior | 0 | |||||
| Benjamin Dippolito | Old Tappan | Junior | 0 | |||||
| Jackson Downey | Old Tappan | Freshman | 0 | |||||
| Chris Mesa | Bergenfield | Senior | 0 | |||||
| Arauki Revi | Bergenfield | Freshman | 0 | |||||
| Sam Nigro | Demarest | Freshman | 0 | |||||
| Tim Nigro | Demarest | Junior | 0 | |||||
| Coach of the year | Rob Ortiz | |||||||
| School | Old Tappan | |||||||