| Big North Conference |
| |
| Patriot |
| Softball |
| 2011-2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Ashley DeYoung | Indian Hills | Senior | First Base |
| Lexi Knief | Ramsey | Senior | Infield |
| Morgan Bishop | Ramsey | Senior | Infield |
| Nicole Leocata | Indian Hills | Sophomore | Infield |
| Sarah Saunders | Mahwah | Senior | Outfield |
| Carey Houston | Indian Hills | Senior | Outfield |
| Nicole Gravalis | Ramsey | Senior | Outfield |
| Nicole Paiotti | Indian Hills | Sophomore | Catcher |
| Kayla Gravalis | Ramsey | Junior | Catcher |
| Ally Mende | Ramsey | Senior | Pitcher |
| Danielle Iacovo | Mahwah | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| Arielle Schlmann | Ramsey | Senior | At Large |
| Catherine Ursillo | Bergenfield | Freshman | At Large |
| Julianne Vesce | Mahwah | Junior | At Large |
| | | | |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| Julianne Darcey | Pascack Valley | Senior | First Base |
| Alyssa Baldi | Mahwah | Freshman | Infield |
| Kristen Waters | Indian Hills | Junior | Infield |
| Melissa Gwon | Ramsey | Senior | Infield |
| Madison Levine | Indian Hills | Sophomore | Outfield |
| Rhianna Maglio | Ramsey | Senior | Outfield |
| Sofie Check | Tenafly | Sophomore | Outfield |
| Stephanie Miranda | Bergenfield | Junior | Catcher |
| Katie Clarke | Mahwah | Junior | Catcher |
| Victoria Miranda | Bergenfield | Junior | Pitcher |
| Devin Durando | Indian Hills | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | |
| Rachel Ravettine/Taylor Alexander | Mahwah | Senior | |
| Morgan Levine, 12/Julia Ferraro, 10 | Indian Hills | | |
| Molly Hopkins/Nicole Steccato | Bergenfield | Senior | |
| Re Anne Kleinbard, 12/Melanie Consiglio,11 | Ramsey | | |
| Lindsay Clark,11/Jordan Bastable,12 | River Dell | | |
| Amanda Rachel Garcia/Jackie Clifford | Tenafly | Junior | |
| Gabby Slad (10)/ Alexa McManus (11) | Passaic Valley | | |
| |
| Coach of the year | Chris Caserta |
| School | Ramsey |
