| Big North Conference |
| |
| Liberty |
| Softball |
| 2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| AMANDA MAROKOVITZ | CLIFTON | Junior | FIRST BASE |
| KAYLA MENEGHIN | CLIFTON | Junior | SECOND BASE |
| MARIA AMEZQUITA | PASSAIC | Senior | SHORT STOP |
| IVORY ALLEN | PCTI | Sophomore | THIRD BASE |
| DYLAN AMICO | CLIFTON | Sophomore | CATCHER |
| ALEXSANDRA MALCOLM | PASSAIC | Senior | PITCHER |
| MARGIE AMAYA | PCTI | Senior | PITCHER |
| CALLIE SHANAHAN | CLIFTON | Senior | PITCHER |
| ZIGMARY COLON | PCTI | Senior | OUT FIELD |
| RENEE KORCZYNSKI | CLIFTON | Senior | OUT FIELD |
| EMILY LEDESMA | PASSAIC | Senior | OUT FIELD |
| BRIANNA BEASE | PCTI | Senior | OPEN |
| MEGHAN FAHY | CLIFTON | Senior | OPEN |
| JANINE GIORDANO | CLIFTON | Junior | OPEN |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| ALLISON HOEY | CLIFTON | Senior | FIRST BASE |
| ALEXIS ISOM | PCTI | Junior | SECOND BASE |
| LUCY DELACRUZ | KENNEDY | Junior | SHORT STOP |
| DESIREE RODRIGUEZ | PASSAIC | Sophomore | THIRD BASE |
| MILITZA RIVERA | PASSAIC | Junior | CATCHER |
| KIANA MALCOLM | PASSAIC | Sophomore | PITCHER |
| CHAZ WOZNEY | PCTI | Sophomore | PITCHER |
| NAZIMA ALI | EASTSIDE | Junior | PITCHER |
| SHA’ASHA SANDERS | PASSAIC | Junior | OUT FIELD |
| HEATHER RANGES | CLIFTON | Junior | OUT FIELD |
| TATJIANA AGUIRRE | PCTI | Junior | OUT FIELD |
| JEN CHUPICK | CLIFTON | Junior | OPEN |
| LAURA AVILA | PASSAIC | Junior | OPEN |
| TAMIRA EASTERLING | PCTI | Sophomore | OPEN |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | |
| CARELY GENAO AND ELIZABETH KAY | PCTI |
| NEEHA CORLEY AND JENNIFER QUINONES | PASSAIC |
| KELLY YOUNG AND CHRISTINA HLAVATY | CLIFTON |
| ALENDRIA TEJADA AND EYMI EDUARDO | EASTSIDE |
| CRISMERY CRUZ | KENNEDY |
| |
| Coach of the year | SAL ANZALDI | |
| School | CLIFTON |
