| Big North Conference |
| |
| Independence |
| Softball |
| 2012 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| CRISTINA COPPOLA | WEST MILFORD | Junior | FIRST BASE |
| BRIANNA HULBERT | WAYNE HILLS | Freshman | SECOND BASE |
| MICHELLE COYLE | WEST MILFORD | Senior | SHORT STOP |
| ERIN WITHERSPOON | WEST MILFORD | Senior | THIRD BASE |
| JAMIE POSPISHIL | WAYNE HILLS | Senior | CATCHER |
| JENNIFER STOLL | LAKELAND | Freshman | PITCHER |
| NIKI CARILLO | WAYNE VALLEY | Junior | PITCHER |
| KATE KALLERT | PASSAIC VALLEY | Junior | PITCHER |
| LINAH MUNEM | PASSAIC VALLEY | Senior | OUT FIELD |
| HALEY PALADINO | WEST MILFORD | Senior | OUT FIELD |
| CARLY SOOJIAN | WAYNE HILLS | Junior | OUTFIELD |
| JAMIE YARRISH | PASSAIC VALLEY | Senior | OPEN |
| CHRISHNA FABIANO | WAYNE HILLS | Sophomore | OPEN |
| ALLIE YOFFEE | LAKELAND | Freshman | OPEN |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position |
| MADISON GALLIGAN | WAYNE VALLEY | Junior | FIRST BASE |
| JASMINE SCONCIAFURNO | PASSAIC VALLEY | Senior | SECOND BASE |
| LAUREN BERRY | LAKELAND | Sophomore | SHORT STOP |
| CASSANDRA GERARD | WAYNE VALLEY | Freshman | THIRD BASE |
| LIZ DEVENIO | PASSAIC VALLEY | Senior | CATCHER |
| MELANIE CIECIUCH | WAYNE HILLS | Sophomore | PITCHER |
| VICTORIA TORP | WEST MILFORD | Sophomore | PITCHER |
| MISSI TOWNSEND | WEST MILFORD | Junior | PITCHER |
| MEGAN GOLISH | WAYNE VALLEY | Junior | OUT FIELD |
| TINA BRINDISI | LAKELAND | Junior | OUT FIELD |
| SHANNON DILLON | PASSAIC VALLEY | Senior | OUT FIELD |
| ALANA LUNA | WAYNE HILLS | Sophomore | OPEN |
| MACKENZIE PORCH | WEST MILFORD | Sophomore | OPEN |
| PAIGE ZELITSKY | LAKELAND | Senior | OPEN |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | |
| KRISTINA BRONKOWSKI AND MIKAYLA MELENDEZ | PASSAIC VALLEY |
| SUSAN PASQUARIELLO AND KELLY BURIAN | WAYNE HILLS |
| LINDSEY LICHTENBERGER AND SHAYNA OCELLO | WAYNE VALLEY |
| NICOLE MAHONEY AND CELESTE POHL | LAKELAND |
| AMBER MAZZOCCHI AND JENNY COYLE | WEST MILFORD |
| |
| Coach of the year | LAURA KING |
| School | LAKELAND |
