All-Division: National
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| National | ||||||||
| Softball | ||||||||
| 2018 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| MAKENZIE MCGRATH | DEMAREST | Senior | PITCHER | |||||
| CLARA FRANCIS | OLD TAPPAN | Junior | PITCHER | |||||
| JANIAH LUCIANO | TEANECK | Senior | CATCHER | |||||
| LINDSEY GERMANO | OLD TAPPAN | Senior | FIRST BASE | |||||
| ELLEN HAMLIN | DEMAREST | Senior | INFIELD | |||||
| REBECCA CLYDE | OLD TAPPAN | Junior | INFIELD | |||||
| NICOLE FRANKLIN | PASCACK VALLEY | Senior | INFIELD | |||||
| JULIA SPADAFINO | PASCACK VALLEY | Junior | OUTFIELD | |||||
| MEGAN WEIS | OLD TAPPAN | Junior | OUTFIELD | |||||
| SELENA DAVIS | TEANECK | Junior | OUTFIELD | |||||
| CYNTHIA GORDON | OLD TAPPAN | Junior | OPEN | |||||
| ELIZABETH REVEREND | DEMAREST | Sophomore | OPEN | |||||
| OLIVIA FELLBAUM | BERGENFIELD | Senior | OPEN | |||||
| ERIN EMERY | TEANECK | Junior | OPEN | |||||
| – | ||||||||
| – | ||||||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| SOPHIA GOTTDIENER | TEANECK | Senior | PITCHER | |||||
| CARA MCMAHON | PASCACK VALLEY | Sophomore | PITCHER | |||||
| BRADEN RENKE | DEMAREST | Junior | CATCHER | |||||
| AMBER IMPROGO | TEANECK | Senior | FIRST BASE | |||||
| CALISTA ZAHOS | OLD TAPPAN | Junior | INFIELD | |||||
| MADISON TREDO | DEMAREST | Sophomore | INFIELD | |||||
| LAUREN MCGRIFF | TEANECK | Senior | INFIELD | |||||
| KATARINA FELIX | BERGENFIELD | Senior | OUTFIELD | |||||
| SYDNIE WEINBERGER | OLD TAPPAN | Senior | OUTFIELD | |||||
| KAYLA VENTURA | TEANECK | Junior | OUTFIELD | |||||
| EMILY MORILLO | BERGENFIELD | Senior | OPEN | |||||
| SINEAD ALBELLI | OLD TAPPAN | Sophomore | OPEN | |||||
| MARGAUX LESSER | TEANECK | Sophomore | OPEN | |||||
| SILVIA ACOSTA | TENAFLY | Senior | OPEN | |||||
| – | ||||||||
| – | ||||||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| CAROLYN GOODMAN | OLD TAPPAN | Junior | ||||||
| GABRIELLA RAMUNDO | OLD TAPPAN | Junior | ||||||
| MEADOW GARCIA | DEMAREST | Junior | ||||||
| SAMANTHA O’DONNELL | DEMAREST | Senior | ||||||
| ERIN FLANAGAN | PASCACK VALLEY | Senior | ||||||
| ISABELLA RUSSANICH | PASCACK VALLEY | Senior | ||||||
| KRISTIN MENA | BERGENFIELD | Freshman | ||||||
| ARIANNY RODRIGUEZ | BERGENFIELD | Senior | MIKA RIVERA | |||||
| MIKA RIVERA | TEANECK | Junior | ||||||
| KAYLA MERROW | TEANECK | Junior | ||||||
| EMILY CAMIZZI | TENAFLY | Senior | ||||||
| SAM LAWRENCE | TENAFLY | Sophomore | ||||||
| – | ||||||||
| Coach of the year | JERRY HILL | |||||||
| School | ||||||||