All-Division: United
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| United | ||||||||
| Softball | ||||||||
| 2016 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Olivia Sprofero | IHA | Junior | Pitcher | |||||
| Summer Ramundo | DePaul | Sophomore | Pitcher | |||||
| Dominique Coiro | DePaul | Sophomore | Catcher | |||||
| Emilie Cieslak | IHA | Senior | First Base | |||||
| Danielle Trongone | DePaul | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Taylor Kenerson | IHA | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Reagan Jones | IHA | Junior | Infield | |||||
| Jennifer McGann | AHA | Sophomore | Outfield | |||||
| Reese Guevarra | IHA | Junior | Outfield | |||||
| Sydney Fleming | DePaul | Junior | Outfield | |||||
| Morgan O’Neill | DePaul | Junior | Open | |||||
| Zoe Cockinos | AHA | Senior | Open | |||||
| Sabrina Torres | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Open | |||||
| Victoria Robinson | AHA | Freshman | Open | |||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Margaret Flahive | AHA | Sophomore | Pitcher | |||||
| Noelle Cancro | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Catcher | |||||
| Laura Pesanello | AHA | Sophomore | Catcher | |||||
| Julianna Longo | Paramus Catholic | Junior | First Base | |||||
| Christina Careri | AHA | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Kaitlin Cavangh | DePaul | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Sonia Sharma | IHA | Sophomore | Infield | |||||
| Alexandra Serek | DePaul | Senior | Outfield | |||||
| Tori Casey | IHA | Senior | Outfield | |||||
| Julianna Golembiski | Paramus Catholic | Junior | Outfield | |||||
| Brianna Gangl | AHA | Freshman | Open | |||||
| Sarah Sicalari | IHA | Senior | Open | |||||
| Gabrielle D’Amato | Paramus Catholic | Senior | Open | |||||
| Nicole D’Ambrosia | DePaul | Freshman | Open | |||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Brooke Heideger | AHA | Senior | ||||||
| Sabrina Fitzpatrick | AHA | Senior | ||||||
| Jaymie Patacco | DePaul | Junior | ||||||
| Bianca Muscato | DePaul | Sophomore | ||||||
| Allessandra Mania | Paramus Catholic | Senior | ||||||
| Adrian Acakios | Paramus Catholic | Senior | ||||||
| Sarah Browning | IHA | Senior | ||||||
| Taylor Gallagher | IHA | Senior | ||||||
| Coach of the year | Diana Fasano | |||||||
| School | IHA | |||||||