All-Division: National
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| National | ||||||||
| Softball | ||||||||
| 2016 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Makenzie McGrath | Demarest | Sophomore | Pitcher | |||||
| Julie Rodriguez | Old Tappan | Junior | Pitcher | |||||
| Carol Oberhelman | Old Tappan | Senior | Catcher | |||||
| Alexandra Pleasic | Pascack Valley | Senior | First Base | |||||
| Veronica Corcoran | Demarest | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Lauren McGriff | Teaneck | Sophomore | Infield | |||||
| Ashley LaGrosa | Pascack Valley | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Victoria Corcoran | Demarest | Senior | Outfield | |||||
| Julia Spinelli | Old Tappan | Senior | Outfield | |||||
| Ashley Sosa | Teaneck | Junior | Outfield | |||||
| Megan Zaccario | Tenafly | Senior | Open | |||||
| Jessica Gorman | Bergenfield | Junior | Open | |||||
| Ellen Hamlin | Demarest | Sophomore | Open | |||||
| Haley Pontillo | Demarest | Senior | Open | |||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Kayla Merrow | Teaneck | Freshman | Pitcher | |||||
| Isabel Deleon | Bergenfield | Senior | Pitcher | |||||
| Janiah Luciano | Teaneck | Sophomore | Catcher | |||||
| Jessica Muti | Demarest | Senior | First Base | |||||
| Samantha Maniscalco | Demarest | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Nicole Franklin | Pascack Valley | Senior | Infield | |||||
| Olivia Fellbaum | Bergenfield | Sophomore | Infield | |||||
| Sydnie Weinberger | Old Tappan | Sophomore | Outfield | |||||
| Michelle Diehl | Demarest | Junior | Outfield | |||||
| Christine Franklin | Pascack Valley | Senior | Outfield | |||||
| Erin Emery | Teaneck | Freshman | Open | |||||
| Clara Francis | Old Tappan | Freshman | Open | |||||
| Sophia Gottdiener | Tenafly | Sophomore | Open | |||||
| Ashley Hansen | Bergenfield | Senior | Open | |||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Selena Davis | Teaneck | Freshman | ||||||
| Mika Rivera | Teaneck | Freshman | ||||||
| Nicole Dehn | Pascack Valley | Senior | ||||||
| Cara McMahon | Pascack Valley | Freshman | ||||||
| Brianna Deleon | Bergenfield | Junior | ||||||
| Taylor Hansen | Bergenfield | Senior | ||||||
| Pam Ng | Demarest | Senior | ||||||
| Claudia Mattes | Demarest | Junior | ||||||
| Nina Einsidler | Tenafly | Senior | ||||||
| Maia Katz | Tenafly | Sophomore | ||||||
| Lindsey Germano | Old Tappan | Sophomore | ||||||
| Calista Zahos | Old Tappan | Freshman | ||||||
| Coach of the year | Keith Johnson | |||||||
| School | Demarest | |||||||