All-Division: United
| Big North Conference | ||
| United | ||
| Girls Volleyball | ||
| 2017 | ||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year |
| Catherine Fazio | Immaculate Heart | Senior |
| Julia Morris | Immaculate Heart | Senior |
| Colette Petric | Immaculate Heart | Senior |
| Anna Morris | Immaculate Heart | Sophomore |
| Sydney Taylor | Immaculate Heart | Junior |
| Erica Timpanaro | Immaculate Heart | Senior |
| Jamie Averna | Paramus Catholic | Senior |
| Vanessa Lomakin | DePaul | Junior |
| Jalen Wynn | Holy Angels | Sophomore |
| Magda Papenhausen | Holy Angels | Junior |
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year |
| Kaela Wong | Immaculate Heart | Senior |
| Emily Taufield | Holy Angels | Junior |
| Danielle Lagomarsino | Paramus Catholic | Junior |
| Maya Jarkowsky | Paramus Catholic | Sophomore |
| Brianna Almonte | Paramus Catholic | Junior |
| Erica Ebert | DePaul | Senior |
| Sydney Timorason | DePaul | Senior |
| Angelina Busetto | Holy Angels | Sophomore |
| Daniella Martinez | Holy Angels | Sophomore |
| Nicolette Martinez | Holy Angels | Sophomore |
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year |
| Iris Knowles | Holy Angels | Senior |
| Megan Jones | Paramus Catholic | Senior |
| Jamielyn Juan | DePaul | Sophomore |
| Coach of the year | Maria Nolan | |
| School | Immaculate Heart | |