All-Division: National
| Big North Conference | ||
| National | ||
| Girls Volleyball | ||
| 2017 | ||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year |
| Ellen Hamlin | Demarest | Senior |
| Alicia Iafrate | Demarest | Junior |
| Rachel Suter | Demarest | Senior |
| Ohr Yahalomi | Demarest | Junior |
| Kelly Chen | Old Tappan | Junior |
| Elizabeth Chu | Old Tappan | Senior |
| Camryn Monfried | Old Tappan | Junior |
| Alexandra Trouilloud | Old Tappan | Junior |
| Emma Kropp | Pascack Valley | Junior |
| Megan Viganola | Pascack Valley | Junior |
| Madison Pinnel | Tenafly | Senior |
| Susan Wie | Tenafly | Senior |
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year |
| Julianna Hernandez | Bergenfield | Junior |
| Anna Philpott | Bergenfield | Senior |
| Gianna Arias | Demarest | Junior |
| Sedona Gaard | Demarest | Sophomore |
| Sydney Woods | Demarest | Junior |
| Christina Chu | Old Tappan | Freshman |
| Gianna Fasano | Old Tappan | Sophomore |
| Corinne Herrmans | Pascack Valley | Junior |
| Devin Martinez | Pascack Valley | Senior |
| Sydney Amaro | Teaneck | Sophomore |
| Brigette Candler | Tenafly | Junior |
| Lily Feingold | Tenafly | Sophomore |
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year |
| Olivia Fellbaum | Bergenfield | Senior |
| Samantha O’Donnell | NV-Demarest | Senior |
| Nina Curko | NV-Old Tappan | Senior |
| Laura Cubala | Pascack Valley | Junior |
| Aubreanna James | Teaneck | Junior |
| Angelina Tapia | Tenafly | Sophomore |
| Coach of the year | Beth Powell | |
| School | Demarest | |