American: All-Division
| Big North Conference | |||||
| American | |||||
| Girls Volleyball | |||||
| 2012 | |||||
| 1st Team All-Division | |||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | School | Year | |||
| Katherine Haines | Ridgefield Park | Junior | |||
| Stephanie Aguila | Ridgefield Park | Senior | |||
| Melissa Mayol | Ridgefield Park | Senior | |||
| Irene Kontogiannis | Ridgefield Park | Junior | |||
| Stephanie Nihamin | Fort Lee | Senior | |||
| Defne Guvenic | Fort Lee | Senior | |||
| Hannah Cirone | Fort Lee | Senior | |||
| Jenna Leuck | Dumont | Senior | |||
| Kimberly Johnson | Dumont | Senior | |||
| Jessica Perez | Cliffside Park | Senior | |||
| 2nd Team All-Division | |||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | School | Year | |||
| Nicole Skalamera | Fort Lee | Senior | |||
| Natsumi Ikeda | Fort Lee | Senior | |||
| Natalie Nadoban | Dumont | Senior | |||
| Shaina Carlos | Dumont | Senior | |||
| Sam Levesque | Dumont | Senior | |||
| Emma Petersen | Dwight-Morrow | Junior | |||
| Natalie Gomez | Ridgefield Park | Senior | |||
| Angela Alders | Ridgefield Park | Junior | |||
| Maria Reyes | Cliffside Park | Junior | |||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | |||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | School | Year | |||
| Alivia Sohm | Cliffside Park | Junior | |||
| Jamie Bello | Dumont | Senior | |||
| Giannina Garcia | Dwight-Morrow | Freshman | |||
| Dafne Aguije | Fort Lee | Senior | |||
| Paige MacNeill | Ridgefield Park | Sophomore | |||
| Coach of the year | n/a | ||||
| School | n/a | ||||