| Big North Conference |
| |
| United |
| Girls Swimming & Diving |
| 2016-2017 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Catherine Fazio,Sarah Horne, Kim Caccamo, Nicole Calianese, | IHA | 0 | 200 MR |
| Isabelle Arevalo | IHA | Sophomore | 200 FREE |
| Kelly McDermott | IHA | Freshman | 200 IM |
| Haley Dowd | IHA | Junior | 50 FREE |
| Kim Caccamo | IHA | Senior | 100 FLY |
| Kate Sheridan | IHA | Junior | IHA |
| Amanda Lauer | IHA | Senior | 500 FREE |
| Isabelle Arevalo, Kim Caccamo, Haley Dowd, Kate Sheridan | IHA | – | 200 FR |
| Catherine Fazio | IHA | Junior | 100 BACK |
| Jessalyn Juan | DP | Junior | 100 BREAST |
| Amanda Lauer, Catherine Fazio, Isabelle Arevalo, Kate Sheridan | IHA | – | 400 FR |
| Brianna Gutierrez | PC | Sophomore | OPEN |
| Jamielyn Juan | DP | Freshman | OPEN |
| Sarah Horne | IHA | Junior | OPEN |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Danielle Bonistalli, Gigi Bacquerizo, Emily DeSernia, Haley Dowd | IHA | – | 200 MR |
| Kirstin McGeary | IHA | Sophomore | 200 FREE |
| Kim Caccamo | IHA | Senior | IHA |
| Aiyana Alfinez | PC | Senior | 50 FREE |
| Jamielyn Juan | DP | Freshman | 100 FLY |
| Isabelle Arevalo | IHA | Sophomore | 100 FREE |
| Brianna Gutierrez | PC | Sophomore | 500 FREE |
| Kelly McDermott, Kirsten McGeary, Amanda Lauer, Gigi Bacquerizo | IHA | – | 200 FR |
| Danielle Bonistalli | IHA | Junior | 100 BACK |
| Nicole Calianese | IHA | Sophomore | 100 BREAST |
| Courtney Caccamo, Kristina Organista, Kelly McDermott, Kirsten McGeary | IHA | – | 400 FR |
| Grace Anna Douglas | PC | Senior | OPEN |
| Victoria Schmidt | DP | Senior | OPEN |
| Hailey Krajewski | DP | Freshman | OPEN |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Gigi Bacquerizo | IHA | Freshman | 0 |
| Catherine McLoughlin | Paramus Catholic | Sophomore | 0 |
| Brittney Nickle | De Paul | Senior | 0 |
| |
| Coach of the year | Lia Kunnapas |
| School | IHA |
