All-Division: National
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| National | ||||||||
| Girls Soccer | ||||||||
| 2016 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Jada Usal | Old Tappan | Senior | GK | |||||
| Caroline O’Sullivan | Old Tappan | Junior | DEF | |||||
| Nicole Franklin | Pascack Valley | Junior | DEF | |||||
| Kelly Smith | Pascack Valley | Junior | DEF | |||||
| Carly Rotile | Demarest | Junior | DEF | |||||
| Meredith Glola | Demarest | Junior | DEF | |||||
| Kelly Walsh | NVOT | Senior | MID | |||||
| Arianna Quevedo | Pascack Valley | Sophomore | MID | |||||
| Isabella Ramil | NVOT | Senior | MID | |||||
| Sofia Levinson | Tenafly | Senior | MID | |||||
| Hayley Virone | Bergenfield | Senior | MID | |||||
| Amanda Tripodi | NVOT | Senior | FWD | |||||
| Jordan DeCrescente | NVOT | Junior | FWD | |||||
| Elizabeth Spadafino | Pascack Valley | Junior | FWD | |||||
| Kyra Pialtos | Demarest | Freshman | FWD | |||||
| Maya Mizrahy | Tenafly | Freshman | FWD | |||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Emma Miller | NVD | Sophomore | ||||||
| Mary Adeline Patterson | NVOT | Senior | ||||||
| Rachel White | Pascack Valley | Junior | ||||||
| Bryanna Rosado | Teaneck | Sophomore | ||||||
| Jamie Cottrell | NVD | – | ||||||
| Jennifer LaRocca | Pascack Valley | Senior | ||||||
| Chloe Witt | Pascack Valley | Junior | ||||||
| Izzy Urquiola | NVD | Sophomore | ||||||
| Taylor Newman | NVOT | Sophomore | ||||||
| Jennifer Fernandez | NVOT | Freshman | ||||||
| Jen Marshall | NVD | Junior | ||||||
| Samantha Derrico | NVOT | Freshman | ||||||
| Jordan Mayo | Tenafly | Sophomore | ||||||
| Danielle Freeman | Pascack Valley | Junior | ||||||
| Nahali Tittle | Teaneck | Freshman | ||||||
| Kim Campbell | Bergenfield | Sophomore | ||||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Cleo Pontone | NVOT | – | ||||||
| Kristel Bonastia | Bergenfield | – | ||||||
| Gail Kelly | Teaneck | – | ||||||
| Sabrina Jayson | Teaneck | – | ||||||
| Erin Flanagan | Pascack Valley | – | ||||||
| Fumika Ando | NVD | – | ||||||
| Coach of the year | Amy Lombardo | |||||||
| School | Pascack Valley | |||||||