| Big North Conference |
| |
| National |
| Football |
| 2015 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Jedh Downey | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Tight End |
| Christian Coia | Lakeland | Senior | Tight End |
| Derek Anderson | Indian Hills | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Jake Catalioto | Lakeland | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Alex Waller | Tenafly | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Chris Eicheler | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Sophomore | Tackle |
| Jim DeLuca | Lakeland | Senior | Tackle |
| Stephen Gaffney | Indian Hills | Senior | Guard |
| Marshall Waters | Indian Hills | Senior | Guard |
| Mike Mancuso | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Sophomore | Center |
| Brett Waller | Tenafly | Senior | Running Back |
| Nick Wisnousky | Indian Hills | Senior | Running Back |
| Zachary Denike | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Running Back |
| Kevin Martinez | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Quarterback |
| Tim O’Brien | Indian Hills | Senior | Quarterback |
| Dan Mullin | Lakeland | Senior | Quarterback |
| Yanni Mitropoulous | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Place Kicker |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Ryan Weis | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Junior | Tight End |
| Jessie Wermert | Northern Valley Demarest | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Pat Fontoura | Lakeland | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Matt Stephens | Northern Valley Demarest | Sophomore | Tackle |
| Josh Farjardo | Lakeland | Senior | Tackle |
| Tyler Davis | Indian Hills | Senior | Guard |
| Spencer Kusnic | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Guard |
| Ryan Welch | Tenafly | Junior | Center |
| Nick Andreotto | Indian Hills | Senior | Running Back |
| Austin Albericci | Northern Valley Demarest | Sophomore | Running Back |
| Matean Sedghat | Indian Hills | Senior | Place Kicker |
