All-Division: Colonial (Offense)
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| Colonial | ||||||||
| Football | ||||||||
| 2014 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Chris Voorhis | Paramus | Junior | Tight End | |||||
| Joe Kenny | Wayne Hills | Junior | Tight End | |||||
| Michael Mimmo | Paramus | Senior | Wide Receiver | |||||
| Jack Bors | No. Highlands | Senior | Wide Receiver | |||||
| Andrew Popadics | Wayne Valley | Senior | Wide Receiver | |||||
| Kevin Sula | Paramus | Senior | Tackle | |||||
| Derek Bastinck | Wayne Hills | Senior | Tackle | |||||
| Joe Pierro | Paramus | Senior | Guard | |||||
| Matt Sportelli | Wayne Hills | Junior | Guard | |||||
| Matt Lewis | Paramus | Senior | Center | |||||
| Derek De La Cruz | Paramus | Junior | Running Back | |||||
| Chris Garrone | Wayne Hills | Senior | Running Back | |||||
| Rashaad Rice | Teaneck | Junior | Running Back | |||||
| Tyler Smith | Paramus | Senior | Quarterback | |||||
| Nick Goodwin | Wayne Valley | Junior | Quarterback | |||||
| Richie Holle | No. Highlands | Senior | Quarterback | |||||
| Eric Jankowitz | Wayne Valley | Senior | Place Kicker | |||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Ryan Monteyne | Wayne Valley | Junior | Tight End | |||||
| Vincent Loverde | Wayne Hills | Junior | Wide Receiver | |||||
| Jordan Gamble | Teaneck | Junior | Wide Receiver | |||||
| Mickey Cavagrotti | No. Highlands | Senior | Tackle | |||||
| Frank Petracco | Wayne Hills | Junior | Tackle | |||||
| Jonah Molina | Paramus | Senior | Guard | |||||
| John Duncan | Wayne Valley | Junior | Guard | |||||
| Tyler Rigoli | Wayne Hills | Senior | Center | |||||
| Matt Rosato | No. Highlands | Senior | Running Back | |||||
| Luca Grave | Wayne Hills | Sophomore | Running Back | |||||
| Peter Palczewski | Wayne Hills | Senior | Quarterback | |||||
| John Solomon | No. Highlands | Senior | Guard | |||||
| Gaetano Milazzo | Paramus | Senior | Place Kicker | |||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Frank Falzarano | Wayne Hills | Senior | DB | |||||
| Leyshawn Askew | Wayne Hills | Junior | DE | |||||
| Anthony Feorenzo | Paramus | Senior | WR | |||||
| Emil LaMarca | Paramus | Sophomore | DE | |||||
| Joe Scancarella | Wayne Valley | Sophomore | WR | |||||
| Mike Ludwig | Wayne Valley | Junior | OL | |||||
| Nick Urcivoli | No. Highlands | Senior | LB | |||||
| John Lopez | No. Highlands | Senior | DE | |||||
| Coach of the year | Dan Sabella | |||||||
| School | Paramus | |||||||