Patriot: All-Division (Defense)
| 1ST. TEAM | DEFENSE | ||
| POSITION | ATHLETE | GRADE | SCHOOL |
| LINE | Connor Carlstrom | Sr. | Westwood |
| LINE | Luke Boonstra | Sr. | Mahwah |
| LINE | Austin Berninger | Sr. | Riverdell |
| LINE | Andrew Tummino | Soph. | Riverdell |
| LINE | Warren Lumsden | Jr. | Dwight Morrow |
| L-BACKER | Brandon Gallagher | Soph. | WestWood |
| L-BACKER | Bob Wapelhorst | Sr. | RiverDell |
| L-BACKER | Derek Gaddy | Jr. | Dwight Morrow |
| L-BACKER | Chris Allingham | Sr. | RiverDell |
| D-BACK | Jawann Winfree | Jr. | Dwight Morrow |
| D-BACK | Ryan Duran | Sr. | River Dell |
| D-BACK | Christian DeSanctis | Sr. | River Dell |
| D-BACK | Shawn Doran | Jr. | Mahwah |
| PUNTER | Nick Gentile | Sr. | Fortlee |
| 2ND. TEAM | DEFENSE | ||
| POSITION | ATHLETE | GRADE | SCHOOL |
| LINE | Stephen Soria | Jr. | Mahwah |
| LINE | Nick Harilaou | Sr. | Fortlee |
| LINE | Tariq Bryant | Sr. | Dwight Morrow |
| LINE | Colin Keating | Jr. | Westwood |
| David Bernhart | Sr. | Mahwah | |
| L-BACKER | Anthony Walker | Jr. | Mahwah |
| L-BACKER | Brian Pushie | Soph. | Mahwah |
| L-BACKER | Shawn Cunningham | Jr. | Fortlee |
| L-BACKER | Matt Rivera | Jr. | Westwood |
| D-BACK | Jairus Paul | Soph. | Mahwah |
| D-BACK | Javante Nunnally | Sr. | Dwight Morrow |
| D-BACK | Max Cepeda | Jr. | Riverdell |
| D-BACK | Jacob Williams | Sr. | Fortlee |
| Punter | Jason Stepp | Jr. | Mahwah |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| ATHLETE | SCHOOL | GRADE | |
| Khalil Silas | DWIGHT MORROW | 12 | |
| Clayton Ingram | DWIGHT MORROW | 10 | |
| Masaru Yamaguchi | FORT LEE | 12 | |
| Alex Cheon | FORT LEE | 10 | |
| Raheem Bowens | MAHWAH | 12 | |
| Christopher Smith | MAHWAH | 11 | |
| Tim Barnes | RIVER DELL | 12 | |
| Kevin Barry | RIVER DELL | 12 | |
| Evan Hull | WESTWOOD | ||
| Colin Saunders | WESTWOOD | ||