American: All-Division (Defense)
| 1ST. TEAM | DEFENSE | ||
| POSITION | ATHLETE | GRADE | SCHOOL |
| LINE | Jon Jun | 12 | Pascack Hills |
| LINE | Neil Forrester | 12 | Ramsey |
| LINE | John Richter | 12 | Ridgefield Park |
| LINE | Enes Hoti | 12 | Cliffside Park |
| LINE | Connor Tansey | 12 | Dumont |
| L-BACKER | Noel McGuinness | 12 | Ramsey |
| L-BACKER | Max Spelling | 11 | Pascack Hills |
| L-BACKER | Mike Salvatore | 12 | Ramsey |
| L-BACKER | Mark Alberque | 12 | Ridgefield Park |
| D-BACK | Donald Chisolm | 12 | Ridgefield Park |
| D-BACK | Matt Butler | 10 | Ramsey |
| D-BACK | Tommy LaCoppola | 11 | Dumont |
| D-BACK | Jordan Abend | 12 | Pacack Hills |
| PUNTER | Raul Ferreira | 11 | Ridgefield Park |
| 2ND. TEAM | DEFENSE | ||
| POSITION | ATHLETE | GRADE | SCHOOL |
| LINE | Nick McGuinness | 11 | Ramsey |
| LINE | Adam Avila | 12 | Cliffside Park |
| LINE | Adam Tonner | 10 | Dumont |
| LINE | Deniz Piatt | 12 | Pascack Hills |
| L-BACKER | Arad Terjanian | 12 | Cliffside Park |
| L-BACKER | Andrew Rizo | 11 | Ridgefield Park |
| L-BACKER | Robert Sawyer | 12 | Pascack Hills |
| L-BACKER | Nick Catalano | 11 | Ramsey |
| D-BACK | Deion Velasquez | 11 | Cliffside Park |
| D-BACK | Chris Gormally | 12 | Ramsey |
| D-BACK | Larry McCartney | 11 | Cliffside Park |
| D-BACK | Nick DeGennaro | 10 | Dumont |
| Punter | Tanner Leuck | 9 | Dumont |
| Honorable Mention | |||
| Athlete | School | Grade | |
| Alaa Qandeel | Cliffside Park | 12 | |
| Justin Aquila | Cliffside Park | 10 | |
| Troy Balkum | Dumont | 12 | |
| Dennis Schuck | Dumont | 12 | |
| Robert Stauffer Jr. | Ridgefield Park | 10 | |
| Freddy Garcia | Ridgefield Park | 10 | |
| Andrew Losos | Ramsey | 12 | |
| Kevin Farrina | Ramsey | 12 | |
| Nick Bianco | Pascack Hills | 12 | |
| Trevor Bickel | Pascack Hills | 12 | |
| Coach of the Year | Vic Tribuzio | Ramsey | |
| Sporstmanship | Pascack Hills | ||