All-Division: United
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| United | ||||||||
| Baseball | ||||||||
| 2018 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Matt Seman | Don Bosco | Pitcher | ||||||
| Mike Roll | Bergen Catholic | Pitcher | ||||||
| Jacob Denner | Bergen Catholic | Pitcher | ||||||
| Raul Ortega | St. Joseph Regional | Catcher | ||||||
| Matt Alaimo | St. Joseph Regional | – | First Base | |||||
| Justyn-Henry Malloy | St. Joseph Regional | – | Infield | |||||
| Daniel Helfgott | Don Boso | – | Infield | |||||
| Cade McDermott | Bergen Catholic | – | Infield | |||||
| Ian Maldonado | Bergen Catholic | – | Infield | |||||
| Tommy Courtney | Don Bosco | – | Outfield | |||||
| Gerry Siracusa | Bergen Catholic | – | Outfield | |||||
| Chris Gerard | Bergen Catholic | – | Outfield | |||||
| Johnny Medina | St. Joseph Regional | – | Outfield | |||||
| Evan Bergman | Bergen Catholic | – | Designated Hitter | |||||
| Joshua Rodriguez | St. Joseph Regional | – | Utility | |||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Drew Helmstetter | Don Bosco | – | Pitcher | |||||
| Billy O’Brien | Don Bosco | Sophomore | Pitcher | |||||
| John Anderson | St. Joseph Regional | – | Pitcher | |||||
| Adam Conte | DePaul | – | Catcher | |||||
| Davis Gallagher | St. Joseph Regional | – | First Base | |||||
| John Cohen | Don Bosco | – | Infield | |||||
| Zach Bailey | St. Joseph Regional | – | Infield | |||||
| Anthony Petrosino | Don Bosco | – | Infield | |||||
| Dominic Cancellieri | Bergen Catholic | – | Infield | |||||
| Ryan Carr | Don Bosco | – | Outfield | |||||
| Andrew McDermott | St. Joseph Regional | – | Outfield | |||||
| Pat Zuccola | Bergen Catholic | – | Outfield | |||||
| Santino Manganella | Don Bosco | – | Designated Hitter | |||||
| Steve Sanders | St. Joseph Regional | – | Utility | |||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Andrew Weiland | Don Bosco | – | ||||||
| Justin Cabanas | Don Bosco | – | ||||||
| Jack Rajkowski | St. Joseph Regional | – | ||||||
| John Conforti | St. Joseph Regional | – | ||||||
| Kyle Lesler | DePaul | – | ||||||
| EJ Wolf | DePaul | – | ||||||
| Andrew Rodriguez | Paramus Catholic | – | ||||||
| Jerry Giannoulis | Paramus Catholic | – | ||||||
| Dilon DiBartolomeo | Bergen Catholic | – | ||||||
| Joe Morin | Bergen Catholic | – | ||||||
| Coach of the year | Mike Rooney | |||||||
| School | ||||||||