| Big North Conference |
| |
| National |
| Baseball |
| 2018 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Jake Klag | Pascack Valley | | Pitcher |
| Jordan Issackedes | Pascack Valley | | Pitcher |
| Anthony Pizzi | Northern Valley Old Tappan | | Pitcher |
| Luca Poliandro | Northern Valley Demarest | | Catcher |
| Nick Argenziano | Northern Valley Demarest | – | First Base |
| Patrick DeSalvvo | Tenafly | – | Infield |
| Alex Clyde | Northern Valley Old Tappan | – | Infield |
| Anthony Rota | Northern Valley Demarest | – | Infield |
| Deenae Sujak | Northern Valley Old Tappan | – | Outfield |
| Wilson Richardson | Tenafly | – | Outfield |
| Dan Scachetti | Pascack Valley | – | Outfield |
| Aries Samek | Teaneck | – | Designated Hitter |
| Travis Byrne | Northern Valley Demarest | – | Utility |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Kiernan McElduff | Northern Valley Old Tappan | – | Pitcher |
| Brady Daniels | Teaneck | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| Joe Argenzinno | Northern Valley Demarest | – | Pitcher |
| Dylan Carruba | Tenafly | – | Pitcher |
| Austin Piorkowski | Pascack Valley | – | Catcher |
| Dennis Layne | Bergenfield | – | Catcher |
| Armen Santana | Northern Valley Old Tappan | – | First Base |
| Robert Kraft | Tenafly | – | First Base |
| Jake Lutz | Pascack Valley | – | Infield |
| Mike Gruber | Northern Valley Old Tappan | – | Infield |
| Andrew Chi | Northern Valley Demarest | – | Infield |
| Ricky Lutz | Pascack Valley | – | Outfield |
| John Torres | Teaneck | – | Outfield |
| Endrit Kaleci | Northern Valley Demarest | – | Outfield |
| Will Rodriguez | Northern Valley Old Tappan | – | Designated Hitter |
| Jake Williams | Pascack Valley | – | Designated Hitter |
| Jared Haag | Bergenfield | – | Utility |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Matt Hefter | Northern Valley Demarest | – | |
| Tyler Stimme | Northern Valley Demarest | – | |
| Matt Ramos | Teaneck | – | |
| Michael Tejada | Teaneck | – | |
| Connor Fuster | Bergenfield | – | |
| Daniel Castaneda | Bergenfield | – | |
| Ryan Novakowski | Pascack Valley | – | |
| Niko Orecchio | Northern Valley Old Tappan | – | Nick Piororazio |
| Nick Piororazio | Northern Valley Old Tappan | – | |
| Dylan Carruba | Tenafly | – | |
| |
| Coach of the year | Marc Houser |
| School |
