| Big North Conference |
| |
| American |
| Baseball |
| 2014 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Josh Garcia | Dumont | Junior | Pitcher |
| Justin Nunez | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Pitcher |
| Harry Cohen | Fort Lee | Junior | Pitcher |
| Jordan Jackson | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Catcher |
| Alex Ritter | Fort Lee | Senior | First Base |
| Eddie Nikocevic | Cliffside Park | Junior | Infielder |
| Kevin Barone | Dumont | Junior | Infielder |
| Charles Heslin | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Infielder |
| Ricky Pasternak | Fort Lee | Senior | Infielder |
| Mike DiGirolamo | Dumont | Senior | Outfield |
| Justin Reidy | Dumont | Senior | Outfield |
| Tommy Visaggio | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Outfield |
| Randy Nunez | Fort Lee | Senior | Outfield |
| Carlos Peralta | Cliffside Park | Senior | DH |
| Steven Papadopoulos | Dumont | Senior | Utility |
| | | | |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Avery Oliver | Dumont | Senior | Pitcher |
| Cristian Garcia | Ridgefield Park | Junior | Pitcher |
| Oscar Roca | Cliffside Park | Junior | Pitcher |
| Steven Yelin | Fort Lee | Freshman | Catcher |
| Eric Breun | Dumont | Sophomore | First Base |
| Steve Orozco | Ridgefield Park | Freshman | Infielder |
| Danny Baroni | Dwight Morrow | Freshman | Infield |
| KJ Mortoral | Dumont | Sophomore | Infield |
| Daniel Dripchak | Dumont | Junior | Infield |
| Josh Guzman | Dumont | Senior | Outfield |
| Andrew Rizo | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Outfield |
| Lisandro Ulerio | Dwight Morrow | Freshman | Outfield |
| Cory Hong | Fort Lee | Junior | Outfield |
| Angel Aponte | Ridgefield Park | Senior | DH |
| Liam Connors | Ridgefield Park | Senior | Utility |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Hunter Wrightington | Dumont | Sophomore | |
| Steven Stylianou | Dumont | Junior | |
| Tommy Ochoa | Ridgefield Park | Junior | |
| Ray Lamon | Ridgefield Park | Senior | |
| Horany Fermin | Dwight Morrow | Senior | |
| Ody Castillo | Dwight Morrow | Sophomore | |
| Zach Wielkocz & Anthony Scrivanich | Fort Lee | Junior | |
| Marquis Wright & Tyler Brown | Cliffside Paek | |
